www.elsevier.com/locate/comnet
PerformanceevaluationofSIP-basedmultimediaservices
inUMTS
DirkPesch
aba,*,MariaIsabelPousa,GerryFoster
bCentreforAdaptiveWirelessSystems,CorkInstituteofTechnology,Bishopstown,Cork,Ireland
SystemsEngineeringAnalysisGroup,MotorolaGlobalSystemsSolutionSector,SwindonSN58YQ,UnitedKingdom
Availableonline4June2005
Abstract
WithaneverincreasingpenetrationofIPtechnologiesandthetremendousgrowthinwirelessdatatraffic,thewire-lessindustryisevolvingthemobilecorenetworkstowardsIPtechnology.ThethirdGenerationPartnershipProject(3GPP)hasspecifiedanIPmultimediasub-system(IMS)inUMTSRelease5/6,whichisadjuncttotheUMTSpacket-switched(PS)GPRScorenetwork.ThisIP-basednetworkprovidesfullpacketcallcontrolcapabilitiesbyusingthetext-basedSessionInitiationProtocol(SIP).Initialindications,astothesignallingdelayassociatedwithSIPmes-sages,haveconcernedmobileoperatorsabouttheviabilityofSIPservicesovertheUMTSairinterface.ThisarticleprovidesaninsightintotheUMTSsystemperformance,focusingonselectedUMTSSIP-basedservices.Typicalserviceswithreal-timerequirementssuchasvoiceaswellasdelay-sensitiveandnon-sensitiveapplications,suchasreal-timechatandinstantmessagingservicesareinvestigated.Furthermore,thepaperdiscussesandanalysestherequirementsandpossiblesolutionsforimprovingefficiencyofSIPusageinawirelessenvironmentthroughsignallingprotocolmessagecompression.ResultsofaperformanceevaluationofSIPsignallingscenariosarepresentedintermsoftimedelayandmessageoverloadinthesystem.ResultsshowthatmessagecompressioncanconsiderablyreduceSIPmessagetransmissiontimeontheradioaccessnetworkwhilecorenetworkdelaycontributionsarefoundtobestillhigh.
Ó2005ElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.
Keywords:UMTS;SIPservices;Multimediaservices;Performanceevaluation
1.Introduction
Second-generationwirelesssystems,suchastheglobalsystemformobilecommunications(GSM),wereprimarydesignedtoprovidemobilevoiceservicestotheenduserwithadditionalshort
Correspondingauthor.Tel.:+353214326377;fax:+353214326625.
E-mailaddress:dpesch@cit.ie(D.Pesch).
*13-1286/$-seefrontmatterÓ2005ElsevierB.V.Allrightsreserved.doi:10.1016/j.comnet.2005.05.013
386D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
messagesandlow-rate(9.6kbps)dataservicesinasecondphase.However,withagrowingdemandformobiledataaccessandtheexplosivegrowthofInternetdataservices,wirelessdataapplicationsareseenasamajornewrevenuestream,whichhasspawnedmuchdevelopmentinitiallytowards2.5GservicessuchasGPRSandnowfocusedonthirdgenerationmobilenetworks,i.e.,theuniversalmobiletelecommunicationsystem(UMTS).
UMTSevolvesthemobilecorenetworkto-wardsanallIPtechnologywithanewradionet-workthatprovideshighercapacityanddataratesrequiredforthesupportofadvancedmulti-mediaservices.UMTSintroducesanewradioac-cessnetworkbasedonWCDMAandevolvesthecorenetworktowardsanovelpacket-switchedIP-basedtransportandserviceplatform,theIPmultimediacorenetworksub-system(IMS),whichisspecifiedinUMTSRelease5/6[1].Throughthisalltheassociatedfeaturesofacircuit-switchedcallbecomeavailabletothepacket-switcheduserintheIPdomain.
TheRelease5/6standardsemploytheIETFde-finedtext-basedSessionInitiationProtocol(SIP)[2]astheircallcontrolprotocol.Text-basedproto-colshavetheadvantagethattheyaregenerallyeasiertodevelopthanbit-wisepresentations,buttheirmessagesarelong.SIPmessageoverheadsareverylargeandthereforepotentiallyinefficientforalimitedbandwidthwirelesssystemsuchasUMTS.ThishasmotivatedtheinvestigationofSIPsignallingperformanceandpossibilitiestoim-proveSIP-basedsignalling[3].TheaimoftheinvestigationpresentedhereisthedevelopmentofaUMTSIMSsub-systemmodeldesignedandimplementedinacomputersimulationenviron-ment,compatiblewiththeproposed3GPPstan-dards.ThedevelopedmodelallowstheevaluationofdifferentSIP-basedservicesandtheircapabilitieswithinUMTS,providesforanunder-standingoftheimplicationofintroducingSIP-basedservicesina3Gwirelessnetworks,andyieldsaninsightintotheUMTSsystemperfor-mance.Previouscontributions[4–6]havepre-sentedSIPsignalling,describedSIPservicesin3Gnetworksandhavepointedatpossibleperfor-mancedifficultiesduetothelargeSIPmessagesizes.Theanalysispresentedheregoesbeyond
priorworkinthatitcontributesanewinsightintotheexpectedperformanceofSIPservicesinUMTSbeyondpreviousarticlesandshowshowSIPpro-tocolmessagecompressionhasthepotentialtosig-nificantlyimprovedelayissuesforSIPsignallinginUMTS.
Inthefollowing,webrieflydiscusstheUMTSnetworkarchitecture,thenpresentabriefoverviewofthesessioninitiationprotocolanddescribetheSIPserviceswemodelled:VoiceoverIPandin-stantmessagingwithpresencecapability.ThenwepresentaphysicalreferenceimplementationoftheIMSUMTSarchitectureandpresentthere-sultsofaperformanceevaluationofselectedSIPmultimediaservicesbasedontheUMTSmodel.
2.UMTSRelease5/6IMS
TheUniversalMobileTelecommunicationsSystem(UMTS)isathirdgenerationmobilecom-municationsystemthatprovidesarangeofbroad-bandservices.UMTSRelease99includestwodistinctcorenetworksforsupportofpacket-switched(PS)andcircuit-switched(CS)servicesasdepictedinFig.1.CallcontrolforCSservicesissimilartocallcontrolinGSM.TheUMTSTer-restrialRadioAccessNetwork(UTRAN)consistoftheNodeBandtheRNC,wheretheNodeBoperatesasthebasestationandtheRNCisthecontrollingunitforanumberofNodeBsandforaccesstotheradionetwork.TheServingandGatewayGPRSSupportNodes(SGSN,GGSN)
Fig.1.UMTSfunctionalarchitecture.
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403387
constitutethePSCoreNetwork.EachSGSNisconnectedtoanumberofRNCs,theGGSNisthepointofinterconnectionbetweenexternalnet-worksandUMTSandactsasthegatewayforamobileterminalsÕIPconnection.
AsUMTSevolvestoRelease6,thereisamovetowardsall-IPtechnology,abandoningtheCScorenetworkandprovidingallservicesoverIP.Forthis,thePSCNhasbeenextendedwiththeIPmultimediaCNsub-system(IMS)functionalityallowingmobileoperatorstooffertheirsubscribersmultimediaservicesbasedonInternetapplicationsandprotocols.TheIMScomprisesofallcorenet-workelements,showninFig.2,forprovisionofmultimediaservices.Thisincludesthecollectionofsignallingandbearer-relatednetworkelementsasdefinedin[7,8].TheIMSintroducesthreemainlogicalnetworkelementstotheexistinginfrastruc-ture:CallSessionControlFunction(CSCF),MediaGatewayControlFunction(MGCF),andMediaGateway(MGW).TheHomeSubscriberServer(HSS)isalsointroducedprovidinguserprofileinformationsimilartothatoftodayÕsHLR.
TheCallSessionControlFunction(CSCF)isanSIPserverthatprovides/controlsmultimediaser-vicesforpacket-switchedIPterminals,bothmobileandfixed.TheSessionControlFunctioncantakevariousrolesasdefinedin[9].Proxy-CSCFisthefirstcontactpointfortheUserEquipment(UE)withintheIMSofthelocalnetworktheUEresides
Fig.2.IMSsub-systementities.
in.ItsIPaddressisdiscoveredafteroraspartofasuccessfulPDPcontextactivation.TheP-CSCFforwardsSIPmessagesfromUEtothespecificI-CSCFortotheSIPserver(S-CSCF)actingasaSIPproxy.Serving-CSCFisalwaysassignedinasubscriberÕshomenetwork.Itactsasaregistrarmakinginformationavailablethroughthelocationserver(HSS)andsubsequentlyperformstheses-sioncontrolservicesfortheregisteredendpoint.Ithandlesthesessionstatesonthenetworkforsup-portoftheservices.Interrogating-CSCFisthecon-tactpointwithinanoperatorÕsnetworkforallIMSconnectionsdestinedtoahomeorroamingsub-scribercurrentlylocatedwithinthenetwork.TheI-CSCFalsoobtainstheS-CSCFlinkedwiththeuserintheregistrationprocedureandtheS-CSCFoftheterminatingcounterpartinthesessionestab-lishment.BreakoutGatewayControlFunctiondeterminesthenetworkinwhichthebreakoutintothePSTN/CSdomainistooccur.Oncethenet-workisselected,itselectsaMGCFwhichwillberesponsiblefortheinter-working.
TheMediaGatewayControlFunctioncontrolstheMediaGateway(MGW)andperformstransla-tionofcallcontrolsignallingbetweenPSTNandISDNtypenetworksandSIPsignalling.TheMGWterminatesbearerchannelsfromacircuit-switchednetworkandmediastreamsfromapacketnetwork.TheHSSisthemasterdatabaseforUMTSRelease5/6IPusers.Itcontainsthesubscription-relatedinformationtosupportthenetworkentitieshandlingtheIPsession.ThisentityalsointegratestheHLRfunctionalityforbothpacketandcircuitdomain,whichisthereonconsideredasaHSSsubset.
3.SIP-basedapplications
TheSessionInitiationProtocol(SIP)isanapplication-layercontrolprotocoldevelopedbytheIETFanddefinedin[2].Thistext-encodedpro-tocolwasinitiallydesignedtoestablish,modifyandterminatemultimediasessionswithoneormoreparticipantsinanIPenvironment.However,SIPÕsmobilitysupportandextensibilitymakeitidealtosupportotherservicesandapplications,suchasPresenceandInstantMessaging.SIP
388D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
messagesusetheSessionDescriptionProtocol[10]torequestcertaincharacteristicsofmediastreamsforsessions.
Inthispaper,wehavemodelledandsimulatedseveralSIPcall/sessionsetupscenarios,accordingtothe3GPPspecifications[11]:MobileOriginated(MO)call,destinedtoafixedphone(callee),MobileTerminating(MT)call,whereafixedphone(caller)initiatesthecalltothemobile,andmobile-to-mobile(M2M)callwithtwomobiles,locatedinthesamenetwork.3.1.Presenceoverview
SIPcapabilitieshavebeenextendedtoalsohan-dlePresenceandInstantMessaging(IM)services.Thepresenceservicedefinedin[12]byIETFiscurrentlybeingstandardisedin3GPPRelease6[13,14]forsupportinUMTS.APresenceserviceallowsausertosubscribetootherusersÕstateandbenotifiedofchangesinusersÕstate(e.g.,usergoingoff-line,changingcontactdetails,etc.).Pres-enceanditscombinationwithamessagingserviceandotherservicessuchaspush-to-talkprovidesasimpleandfastwayofcommunicationbetweenonlineusers.Presenceconveystheabilityandwill-ingnessofausertocommunicateacrossasetofdevices(presentity).Fig.3showsthepresencemodelarchitectureasdefinedinIETFRFCanddrafts[12,15].
3.2.Instantmessagingserviceoverview
Theexchangeofcontentbetweencommunicat-ingpartiesinnearrealtimeisrealisedwithinstantmessaging.Typically,thecontentofinstantmes-sagesisshorttextanditstransferistypicallyfastenoughtomaintainsomeformofinteractive
Fig.3.Presenceservice.conversation(chat).EachmessagecanbesentindependentlyusingtheSIPMESSAGEmethod,ormessagescanbeassociatedintosessionsthatareinitiatedusingSIPINVITE.Thefirstapproachisoftenreferredtoaspager-mode,duetoitssimi-laritytothebehaviouroftwo-waypagerdevices,andisusedwhenshortinstantmessagesaresenttoasingleorsmallnumberofrecipients.Incon-trast,thesecondapproach,calledsession-mode,isrequiredforextendedconversations,joiningchatgroups,etc.Bothapproaches,definedbytheIETFSIMPLEgroup,areconsideredinourmodel(seeFig.4).
MessageSessionModel.InthismodeltheIMtrafficisviewedasamediastream,whichispartofanormalSIPsession.Asthedataisalwayssentoverareliablelink,themessagesizeisnotre-stricted.Thismodeloffersadvantageswhenthenumberofmessagesprocessedincreases.OncetheinitialINVITErequesthasbeenprocessed,subsequentSIPmessagessentwithintheestab-lishedsession,bypassanyinterveningSIPproxy.Thereforethemessageloaddecreasesonthoseproxies.Themodelisusedintextconferenceandchatapplicationswhereitisusefulandmoreeffi-cienttohavemessagesassociatedwithsessions.PagingModel.Herenosetuporsessionestab-lishmentisrequiredbeforesendingamessage.ThereforeeachmessageissentindependentlyusingtheMESSAGEmethod.Itmimicstheoper-ationofSMSintodayÕswirelessnetwork.Thismethodhaslimitationsonthemessagesize(<1300bytes)duetonetworkcongestionconcerns.
Fig.4.IMtransportmodels.
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–4033
4.SIPinUMTS
TheSessionInitiationProtocolhasbeenstan-dardisedinUMTSRelease5/6astheapplicationlayersignallingprotocolforpacket-switched(PS)sessionsbetweentheUEandtheIMS.ThenewnetworkelementsintroducedintheIMSactasSIPproxies/serversroutingandhandlingSIPmes-sagesthroughthenetwork.Thisallowsthewire-lessnetworktoprovideasimplevoicetelephonecalltoaPSuseraswellasawiderangeofIP-basedservicessuchasinstantmessagingwithpresence.SIPmessagesinUMTSaretransmittedusingUDP/TCPoverIPovertheappropriateUMTSBearerService.ThisrequiresPDPcontextactiva-tionforIMSsignallingtraffic(SIPsignalling).OnceaPDPcontextisestablishedtheuserper-formsaserviceregistrationwiththeIMS.Afterserviceregistration,theUEcanestablishsessionsusingtheserviceÕsrequiredSIPsignalling.ThenextsectionsprovideabriefoverviewofSIPsig-nallingprocedures.Thepresentedsignallingproce-duresandmessageflowshavebeenimplementedinasimulationenvironmentandtheirperformanceevaluationisdetailedinsubsequentsections.4.1.UMTSsignallingprocedures
Atthestartofapacket-switcheduserapplica-tion,aBearerServiceconnection(PDPcontextwithspecificRadioAccessBearerandRadioBearer)needstobeestablishedtoenabledatatransfer.However,beforeanRNCcancontrol
anyrequestedbearer,itneedstocreateasignallingconnectionbetweentheUEandtheCN.TheRNCusestheRadioResourceControl(RRC)connec-tionservicestocreateoneormoreSignallingRadioBearers(SBRs)betweenUEandtheUTRAN.Thesignallingconnectionsetupproce-dureisshowninFig.5.ItisalwaysinitiatedbytheUE.
4.2.UMTSbearerservice:PDPcontextactivationThePDPContextActivationproceduremaybeinitiatedbytheUEorbythenetworkdependingonthedirectionofthesession.APDPcontextestablishesanassociationbetweentheUEandtheCNforagivenQoSacrossaUMTSBearerService.ItcontainsroutinginformationthatisusedtotransferthePDPPDUsbetweentheUEandtheGGSN.OnceaprimaryPDPcontexthasbeenestablishedforagivenPDPaddress,asecondaryPDPcontextcanbeactivatedwiththealreadyactivePDPcontext,butwithadifferentQoSprofile.Fig.6showsthesignallingflowofthePDPContextActivationprocedure.BesidesacquiringaPDPcontext,theUEalsodiscoverstheaddressoftheProxyCSCFinthenetworkitresidesin.
4.3.IMSsignallingprocedures
OnceaPDPcontexthasbeenestablished,theUEcaninitiateSIPsignallingprocedures.Inthe
Fig.5.RRCconnection.
390D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
Fig.6.PDPcontextactivation.
followingthesignallingflowsforapplicationregistrationandsessionsetupproceduresarebrieflyintroduced.Thosemethodsaregenerallyre-quiredforanyIMSapplication.ThesessionsetupsignallingflowsforvoiceoverIPorinstantmes-sagingsessionsarethenintroduced.Inadditiontothat,theSIPextensionsinSIMPLEfortheIMandPresenceservicearediscussed.
4.3.1.ApplicationlevelSIPregistration
InordertorequestservicesoftheIMSdomain,ausermustperformanapplicationlevelregistration.ThisisdoneonceauserhasanactivatePDPcon-textwithappropriateQoSparametersfortransferofIMS-relatedSIPsignalling.TheQoSparametersspecifiedinPDPcontextactivationmustbeappro-priateforIMSsignalling.Fig.7showstheflowofmessagesforregistrationoftheUEwithitsServingCSCF,assumingtheUEwasnotpreviouslyregis-tered.Asshown,theS-CSCFauthenticatesthemo-bilebeforeregistrationissuccessful.
4.3.2.Subscription
OncethemobileisconnectedtotheIMS,sub-scriptiontothepresenceproviderserversisre-quiredforthoseusersusingpresencecapabilities.Firstthewatcherentitysubscribestoitspresencelistserver(PLS).ThePLSwillthenforwardthesubscriptionrequesttothedesiredpresentityser-ver.Assoonasthemessagearrivesatthepresen-tityserver,allwatcherPLSsareprovidedwithpresentityÕsdetailedinformationandarerequestedtonotifythewatcherentitywiththelatestinfor-mation.Fig.8showsthemessageflowforpresencesubscriptionandwatchernotification.
4.3.3.Sessionsetup
AfterregistrationwiththeIMSandsubscrip-tiontothepresenceservice(whenpresenceisused),theuserisreadytoaccessthemultimediaservicesusingSIPsessioncontrolprocedures.Thesessiontypessupportedinthisanalysisin-cludesessionsetupbetweenmobileandfixed
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403391
Fig.7.SIPregistermethod.
Fig.8.Presencesubscriptionmethod.
392D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
Fig.9.SessionsetupmobiletoPSTN(MO).
phoneforvoicesessionsandmobiletomobilesessionsforinstantmessaging.
Figs.9and10showtheflowofmessagesre-quiredforthesessionsetupbetweenamobileandafixedphone.Fig.9showsthesignallingmes-sageflowforthecasewhenthemobileinitiatesthesession,whereasFig.10showstheflowwhenthefixedphoneinitiatesthesession.Aftermediachar-acteristicsforthesessionhavebeendetermined,re-sourcereservationisrequired,whichentailscreatingasecondaryPDPcontextfortransportoftherequiredmedia,andsettingupthecorre-spondingradioaccessbearers.Fig.11showsthesameSIPmessageexchangetosetupasessionbetweentwomobiles.
5.Simulationmodelandenvironment
InordertoevaluatetheperformanceofSIP-basedmultimediaservicesinUMTSRelease5/6
wehavedevelopedaneventdrivensimulationenvironmentthatallowstheimplementationandsimulationofSIPmessageflowswithinamodelofaUMTSnetwork.Inordertofacilitatetheeffi-cientsimulationofafullUMTSnetworkincludingalargenumberofradioaccessnetworkandcorenetworkelementsaswellasIMSnetworkele-ments,thesimulatorimplementsnetworkelementsasconsistingofprocessorsandfiniteFIFObuffers.Eachprocessorhasaparticularmessageprocess-ingcapabilitywhichisbasedonmeasurementsta-kenfromrealnetworkelements.ThisapproachallowsthesimulationofalargescaleUMTSnet-workmodelsasdetailedinTable1onasinglepro-cessorworkstationwithinareasonabletimeframe.TypicalprocessingtimesforUMTSandSIPsignallingmessagesarebasedonmeasurementsta-kenwithrealnetworkingequipmentincludingNo-deBs,RNCs,SGSN,andGGSN,aswellasatypicalserverplatformsuchasSUNNetraservers.Themessageprocessing(turn-around)timesfor
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403393
Fig.10.SessionsetupPSTNtomobile(MT).
UMTSnetworkelementsandeachelementassoci-atedFIFObufferaresummarisedinTable2(seealsoTables3and4).Networkelementsareinter-connectedusingtypicaltransmissionlinksbasedonE1,STM-1,andEthernet.Weassumethat10%oftheavailabledatarateoneachtransmis-sionlinkisreservedforcontrolsignalling.
Thedynamicsignallingsimulator,SigSim,isdesignedtoestimatetheend-to-endsignallingloadintermsofnumberofmessageshandledpernet-workelementandproceduraldelays.SigSimin-cludesmodelsofusermobilitywithinaparticularenvironmentaswellasuserbehaviourintermsofaccessingdifferentservices.TheeffectsofradiotransmissionbasedonWCDMAarecap-turedinlook-uptablesgeneratedbyaphysicalradiointerfacesimulator.Eventhoughonly
signallingtrafficissimulated,trafficmodelsareimplementedandaccountedfortheperiodoftimeauserisusingaparticularservice.5.1.Networkmodel
Intheprevioussectionwepresentedthefunc-tionalarchitectureoftheIMSasdefinedintheUMTSRelease5/6.However,inordertoanalyseitsperformanceintermsofsignallingfloweffi-ciencyweproposeamorepracticalrealisationhere.Firstthemodelreferenceforthebasicsignal-lingservicesaccordingtoUMTSRelease5specifi-cationsispresented.Thenweadaptthemodeltoincludeenhancedservicesandapplicationcapabil-itiesintroducedinUMTSRelease6includingthePresenceandInstantMessagingservices.
394D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
Fig.11.Mobiletomobilesessionestablishment.
Table1
NetworkconfigurationdataParameter
Numberofcells:(rows·columns)NumberofRNCNumberofSGSNNumberofGGSNNumberofCSCFNumberofMGCFNumberofI-CSCFNumberofHSSURAsizeRAsizeCellradiusDenseurbanUrbanruralSuburbanRural
Value(28,28)
42111112425050010004000
UnitsCells
Table2
NetworkelementprocessingtimesNetworkelementNodeBRNCSGSNGGSNP-CSCFS-CSCFI-CSCFMGCF
Turn-aroundtime(ms)1818
SeeTable3SeeTable425252550
Buffer
size(Mbits)3232323216163232
CellsCellsMeters
Table3
SGSNturn-aroundtimes
5.1.1.BasicUMTSnetworkmodel
Accordingto3GPPspecifications,basicses-sionsbetweenmobileusersalwaysinvolvetwoS-CSCFs(oneforeachuser)andanI-CSCFtoselectthem.Ontheotherhand,asessionbetweenauserandaPSTNendpointinvolvesanS-CSCFfortheUE,aBGCFtoselectthePSTNgatewayanda
SignallingflowtypeMOPDPcontextactivationPDPcontextdeactivationMOservicerequestNIservicerequestRoutingareaupdateSIPsignalling
Turn-aroundtime(ms)394046391950
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
395
Table4
GGSNturn-aroundtimesSignallingflowtypeTurn-aroundtime(ms)MOPDPcontextactivation75NIPDPcontextactivation59PDPcontextdeactivation75SIPsignalling
50
MGCFforthePSTN.Therefore,SIPmessagesareroutedthroughfourSIPproxiesinthemobiletofixedscenario,i.e.,P-CSCF,S-CSCF,BGCFandMGCF.Thisisworseforthemobile-to-mobilecasewhereaP-CSCFandanS-CSCFarerequiredforbothentitiesinadditiontotheI-CSCF,addinguptoatotaloffiveSIPproxiesorservers.ThemoreSIPproxiesthemessagehastotraversethegreaterthetransmissiondelay.Consequently,inordertoreducethetransmissiondelay,weproposetoco-locateIMSlogicalnetworkelementswithsimilarfunctionalityintothreephysicalnodesasillustratedinFig.12.
SIPServerNode.IntegratestheP-CSCFandtheS-CSCFinacommonnodewithinaparticularoperatorÕsnetwork.EverymobilecontactstheIMSthroughaProxy-CSCF.AfterregistrationtheP-CSCFroutestheSIPmessagestotheS-CSCFSIPcontrolelement.TheP-CSCFresidesinthenetworkwherethemobileresides,visitedorhomenetwork,whereastheS-CSCFalwaysresidesinthehomenetwork.Thescenarios
Fig.12.Basicmodelreference.
consideredhereassumedthatallmobilesareintheirhomenetworks,thereforebyco-locatingthosetwoentitiesthenumberofmessagestrans-mittedthroughthenetworkisdecreasedby34%,thusalsoreducingtransmissiondelay.
IMSGatewayNode.Whenthesessionisestab-lishedbetweenamobileuserandaPSTNendpointsuchasafixedtelephoneuser,theBGCFandMGCFhandletheSIPsignallingforthePSTNendpoint.TheBGCF,atthestartofthesessionsetup,selectsthePSTNnetworkwithwhichthein-ter-workingistooccurandforwardsthemessagetothecorrespondingMGCF.AlthoughtheBGCFdoesnothaveconsiderableimpactonthesessionsetup,asitisnotincludedintheSIPmessagepath,thecollocationwiththeMGCFcontributestominimisingmessagetransactiontime.
DatabaseNode.HoststheI-CSCFandtheHSS,whichisalargedatabasewithextendedHLRcapabilities.TheI-CSCFfunctionalityforanon-roaminguserisreducedtocontactingtheHSSforinformation.ItqueriestheHSStoassigntheServing-CSCFattheregistrationpointandalsoobtainstheS-CSCFaddressoftheterminatingcounterpartduringsessionsetup.Thereforeitseemsreasonabletocollocateboth.
5.1.2.EnhancedUMTSnetworkmodel
Thepresenceservice,whichresidesintheIPMultimediaSub-system(IMS),isbeingstandar-disedinRelease6ofthe3GPPstandards[13,14].Thepresenceservermanagesthepresenceinfor-mationofauser(presentity),whichisuploadedbydifferentagents(networkelements,terminalsorexternalelements)andcombinesitintoasinglepresencedocumentinastandardisedXML-basedformat.Furthermore,theserverallowsotherusers(watchers)tosubscribetoitforreceivingpresenceinformation.Forsimplicity,weconsiderthatbothwatcherandpresentityentitiesresideinthesamenetwork,thehomenetwork.Assuch,theycom-municatethroughthehomenetworkÕsCSCFsproxiesandnoexternalagentsareinvolved.Basedonthissimplifiedarchitecture,apracticalrealisa-tionoftheUMTSpresenceservicemodelisproposedhere,wheredifferentelementsarecollo-catedinordertoreducethemessagetransmissiondelay.
396D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
5.3.Trafficmodel
Dependingonthetypeofuserdatacarriedwithinasessionaparticularusertrafficmodelischosen.Intheanalysispresentedhereweconsiderthreetrafficmodels,aconversationalpacketvoiceservice,aninteractive—PagingInstantMessag-ing—andastreaming—MessageInstantMessaging—instantmessagingservice.
ThevoicetrafficmodelisbasedonatwonodeMarkovchainmodelbasedonBradyÕsmodel[16],withtalkspurtsandsilenceperiodsmodelledbyatruncatedexponentialdistribution(seeTable5);themessagingmodelisbasedonahierarchicalUMTSdatamodelbasedon[17]andisshowninFig.15.
ThePagingInstantMessagingserviceusesthesessionandpacketlevelparametersasshowninTable6.Theparametervaluesarebasedonasur-veycarriedoutamongCorkInstituteofTechnol-ogystudents,whereweidentifiedthefrequencyandamountofGSMShortMessagingService(SMS)messagesstudentssendperweek.AsSMSisaparticularlypopularserviceamongthe
Fig.13.Enhancedmodelreference.
Thepresenceserveriscollocatedwiththeregis-terserver,i.e.,theS-CSCF.Furthermore,thewatcherandthepresentityentitiesresideontheUserEquipmentandcommunicatewiththeserveracrosstheSIPproxies,P-CSCF,S-CSCFandI-CSCF.Fig.13showstheconsideredreferenceUMTSarchitectureincludingthetwointroducedapproaches.5.2.Sessionmodel
SessionarrivalsaremodelledbyaPoissonpro-cesswithameansessionholdingtimeof168minwithsessioninter-arrivaltimesdependentonthenextservicerequest(seeFig.14).Eachsessionmayholdoneormoreservices(usersessions)andiftheirQoSsdifferamodificationinthesessionisundertaken.Although3GPPspecificationsallowmorethanonePDPcontextperuserwehaveonlysimulatedsinglePDPcontexts.
Table5
VoicetrafficmodelparametersLevelSession
ParameterArrivalrate
DurationTalk-SpurtSilent
UnitsSession/hsss
DistributionTruncatedexponentialTruncatedexponentialTruncatedexponentialTruncatedexponential
Mean1.612011.3
Periods
Fig.14.Sessionmodel.
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403397
Fig.15.Packetservicesessionmodel.
Table6
Paginginstantmessagingparameters,1/l=mean,T=trunca-tionvalueLevelParameterUnits
DistributionUL/DL
values
Session
ArrivalSession/dayTruncated
l=2.9rate
exponential
T=0.36Duration
sTruncated
1/l=5exponential
T=250Packet
SizeBytesTruncated
l=160pareto
T=1000Inter-arrivalsTruncated
1/l=0.032exponential
T=1000
15–24-yearagegroupinIreland,wefeltthatsuchasurveywouldyieldareasonableexpectationforthesessionsgeneratedinafutureUMTS-basedmobileinstantmessagingservice.
TheMessageInstantMessagingserviceparame-tersforsession,file,andpacketsizedistributionareshowninTable7,andarebasedonfigurespublishedin[18].
6.Performancecharacteristics
InordertoobtainperformancecharacteristicsforSIP-basedmultimediasessionsinUMTSRe-lease5/6wehavesimulatedpacket-voicecallsetupdelaysformobileoriginatedandterminatedcallinitiationandforthetwoinstantmessagingschemesusingthemodelspresentedabove.First
Table7
Messageinstantmessagingparameters,1/l=mean,T=trun-cationvalueLevelParameterUnitsDistributionUL/DLvaluesSession
ArrivalrateSession/dayTruncatedl=1.7exponentialT=0.36Duration
MinTruncated1/l=7.5exponentialT=15FileSize
UnitsGeometricn=188Inter-arrivalUnitsGeometricn=5Packet
SizeBytesTruncatedl=80paretoT=1000Inter-arrival
Sec.
Truncatedl=0.024exponential
T=1000
wepresenttypicalSIPmessagesizesonwhichthesignallingflowsformultimediaservicesarebasedandthenwepresentresultsforsessionsetupdelaysforvoiceandinstantmessagingsessions.6.1.SIPmessagesizes
InordertoanalyseSIP-basedmultimediases-sionsetupandmessagetransmissiondelays,weas-sumedSIPmessagesizesshowninTables8–12.AcriticalissuewithSIPmessagesisthattheyaresubstantialinsizecomparedtothebinaryencodedcallcontrolmessagesusedinGSMorUMTSRe-lease99.Asshownintheperformanceanalysis,SIPmessagesizescontributetosignificantdelayontheradioaccessnetworkofUMTS.Oneap-proachtoreducethedelayistocompressSIPmes-sages.TheIETFROHCgrouphasproposedaSIPmessagecompressionframeworkcalledSigComp[19]togetherwithanumberofcompressionmeth-ods.Intheperformanceevaluationpresentedhere,weusetheText-basedCompressionusingtheCacheandBlank(TCCB)approach[20,21],whichachievesveryhighcompressionratiosandcontri-butestoasignificantdelayreduction.
Tables8and9showtypicalSIPmessagesizesofsignallingflowsformobileoriginatedandmo-bileterminatedpacket-voicecallsetup.Itisobvi-ousthatmessagesizesaresubstantialbutusingTCCBcompression,messagescanbecompressedandreducedbyupto92%inthecaseofa180Ringingmessagesforexample.
398D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
Table8
MobileoriginatedsessionSIPsignallingmessagesizesUPLINKINVITEHeaderSDPTotalUPDATEHeaderSDPTotal
PRACK(180)Total(SDP=0)ACK
Total(SDP=0)DOWNLINK183SessionProgressHeaderSDPTotal180Ringing
Total(SDP=0)200OKHeaderSDPTotal
UE
Notcompressed507229736352194546370314P-CSCFNotcompressed614233847361363194557
Compressed2027427629257095
676867929383
Compressed310190500982111910691
Compressionratio(%)39173272787171
Table10showsSIPmessagesizesfortheRegis-termethodincludingsignallingforapplicationlevelauthenticationwithandwithoutSIPmessagecompressionbasedonTCCB.Herewedonotachievethesameimpressivecompressionratiosasachievedinotherflowssuchassessionsetup.ThereasonisthattheTCCBapproachcachespre-viousSIPmessagecontentandblanksitoutforsubsequentSIPmessages.AstheRegistermethodistypicallythefirstSIPflow,cachecontentislim-itedornotavailableatthatstageandthecompres-sionratioislow[19].
Tables11and12showthemessagesandtheirrespectivesizeswithandwithoutmessagecom-pressionfortheSIPsubscribemethodusedforsubscribingtoanotheruserÕsbuddylistandthemobile-to-mobileSIPsessionsetupdelayfortheMessageInstantMessagingflow.Substantialreductionsinmessagesizesareachievedwithcom-pressionandtheperformanceevaluationshowstheimprovementinsignallingdelayreduction.
6.2.Voicecallsetupdelayanalysis
WehavesimulatedthesignallingflowshowninFig.9inthenetworkmodeldescribedabove.Theresultswereobtainedbasedonthebasicnetworkmodeldescribedabove,thenetworkconfigurationdetailedinTable1andatotalof210,000usersroamingtheUMTSnetwork.InordertoallowacomparisonwithUMTSRelease99CallControl,weconsideredthatSIPsignallingmessageswouldbecarriedina3.4kb/sDTCHasallUMTSsignal-lingistransmittedona3.4kb/sradiobearerwithMACblocksizeof136[22].Table13showstheUMTSRelease99circuit-switchedcallsetupde-laysasobtainedwiththeSigSimsimulationenvi-ronment.WecancomparethistoaUMTSRelease5/6packetvoicecallsetupdelayusingSIPsignallingasshowninTable14.WecanseesignificantsessionsetupdelaysusingSIPsignallingontheradiointerfaceandintheIMScomparedtoUMTSRelease99callsetupdelays.Duetoa
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
Table9
MobileterminatedsessionSIPsignallingmessagesizesDOWNLINKINVITEHeaderSDPTotal
PRACK(183)HeaderSDPTotal
PRACK(180)Total(SDP=0)ACK
Total(SDP=0)UPLINK
183SessionprogressHeaderSDPTotal180Ringing
Total(SDP=0)200OKHeaderSDPTotal
P-CSCFNotcompressed6342268603751965713315P-CSCFNotcompressed5181967143613194558
Compressed219943139610170171
585256737269
Compressed47618766332573043
2517239171849286
399
Compressionratio(%)
Table10
SIPregistermethodmessagesizesUPLINK
REGISTER
Total(Body=0)REGISTERAuth.Total(Body=0)DOWNLINK401unauthorisedTotal(Body=0)200OK
Total(Body=0)
UE
Notcompressed534639P-CSCFNotcompressed363426
Compressed203218
4449
Compressed429405
2037
Compressionratio(%)
significantdelayontheradiointerface,weproposetocompressSIPmessagesusingSIPmessagecom-pressiontechniquessuchastheText-basedCom-pressionusingCacheandBlank(TCCB)orothermethodsasproposedbytheIETFROHCgroup.EmployingSIPmessagecompressionreducestheRANdelayby66%(seeTable14)withanoverallreductioninsessionsetupdelayof46%.EventhoughSIPmessagecompressionreducesdelay,othermeanshavetobefoundtobringthe
400
Table11
SIPsubscribemethodmessagesizesUPLINK
SUBSCRIBE
Total(Body=0)200OK
Total(Body=0)DOWNLINK
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
UE
Notcompressed472215P-CSCFNotcompressed
Compressed102276322
FunctionCompressed296112
Compressionratio(%)
3748
200OK
Total(Body=0)NOTIFY
Total(XML=0)NOTIFY(state)HeaderXML
302420458
Function
663430
Function
Table12
Mobile-to-mobileSIPinstantmessagingsessionsetupmessagesizesUPLINKINVITEHeaderSDPTotalUPDATEHeaderSDPTotal
PRACK(180)Total(SDP=0)ACK
Total(SDP=0)DOWNLINK183SessionProgressHeaderSDPTotal180Ringing
Total(SDP=0)200OK
Total(SDP=0)
UE
Notcompressed424184608300184484288263P-CSCFNotcompressed500184684293263
Compressed302184486103102
400296561
Compressed2051843142184326147137
52036530334948
Compressionratio(%)
SIP-basedcallsetupintosimilardelayregionsasUMTSRelease99.Oneapproachistoco-locatenetworkelementsintheIMStoreducemessagetransmissionacrossexternalinterfacesortobaseIMSnetworkelementsonhigh-performanceserv-erswithhighermessagethroughputthancurrent
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
401
Table13
UMTSRelease99circuit-switchedcallsetupdelayFlowID
Meandelay(s)RANCoreTotalMOUMTSCScallsetup1.350.551.90MTUMTSCScallsetup
1.63
0.66
2.28
Table14
MobileoriginatedSIPcallsetupdelayFlowID
SIPcompr.Meandelay(s)RANCoreTotalPrimaryPDPcontextN/A1.570.772.34MOSIPsessionsetupOff4.381.936.31MOSIPsessionsetupOn1.491.933.42SecondaryPDPContext
N/A
1.18
0.76
1.94
referenceequipmentascorenetworkdelaystillcontributestoover50%delaywhenSIPmessagecompressionisenabled.
CallsetupdelaysforPSTNoriginatedandmo-bileterminatedcallinitiationusingSIPsignallingisshowninTable15.Herewecanobservesimilarresultsasinthemobileoriginatedcase.
Inordertoassestheimpactofthelowbitrate3.4kb/ssignallingbearerusedforcallsetupdelaysimulation,wesimulatedthesamemobileorigi-natedandmobileterminatedSIPcallsetupusingakb/sdatabearerwithaMACblocksizeof1280.Theuseofkb/sbearersinsteadofa3.4kb/scontrolsignallingbearerandusingSIPmessagecompressionbringsmobileoriginatedcallsetupalmostinlinewithUMTSRelease99delaysandmobileterminatedcallsetupdelaysarecom-parableifnotbetterthanUMTSRelease99callsetupdelaysasshowninTables16and17.Inboth
Table15
MobileterminatedSIPcallsetupdelayFlowID
SIPcompr.Meandelay(s)RANCoreTotalNIPDPcontextN/A2.1.674.31activation
MTSIPsessionsetupOff4.911.566.47MTSIPsessionsetupOn1.971.3.61SecondaryPDPcontext
N/A
1.18
0.76
1.94
Table16
MobileoriginatedSIPcallsetupdelay,kb/sbearerFlowID
SIPcompr.
Meandelay(s)RANCoreTotalMOSIPsessionsetupOff0.701.902.6MOSIPsessionsetupOn0.251.902.15SecondaryPDPcontext
N/A
1.18
0.76
1.94
Table17
MobileterminatedSIPcallsetupdelay,kb/sbearerFlowID
TCCBDelay(s)RANCoreTotalMTSIPsessionsetupOff0.751.632.38MTSIPsessionsetupOn0.341.631.97SecondaryPDPcontext
N/A
1.18
0.76
1.94
casesthemaincontributingfactortodelayisthecorenetwork.ThisrequiresacarefulchoiceforcorenetworkSIPservercomputingplatformsinordertoachieveservicequalityintermsoflowcallsetupdelaysforfutureUMTSIMS-basedmulti-mediaservices.
6.3.Instantmessagingserviceanalysis
Resultsobtainedfortheinstantmessagingser-viceanalysisarebasedon5hofsimulatedreal-timeand10,000IMusersintheUMTSnetwork.TheenhancedUMTSnetworkmodeldescribedabovewasimplementedintheSigSimsimulator.Akb/sdatabearerisusedontheUMTSradioaccessnetworktotransmitSIPmessages.Table18
Table18
Mobile-to-mobilemessageinstantmessaging(streaming),with-outSIPmessagecompressionFlowID
Meandelay95%DelayRANCoreTotaltotalPSsessionsetup1.460.772.233.36SIPregistration0.410.881.281.48SIPsubscriptionLS0.240.530.760.SIPsubscription0.160.350.510.56presentity
MMOSIPsessionsetup
0.82
1.25
2.07
2.39
402D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403
Table19
Mobile-to-mobilemessageinstantmessaging(streaming),withSIPmessagecompressionFlowID
SIPregistrationSIPsubscriptionLS
SubscriptionpresentityMOMMOSIPsessionsetupSubscriptionpresentityMTMMTSIPsessionsetupSIPnextsubscriptionNextMMOinvite
MeanDelayRANCoreTotal0.310.170.140.5800.710.160.41
0.880.530.351.250.051.030.451.25
1.190.700.491.830.051.740.611.66
95%Totaldelay1.330.780.512.010.051.740.701.87
showsthemeansignallingdelaysinregisteringwithanSIPserver,subscribingtoapresentity,andthesessionsetupfortransmittinginstantmes-sages.Thetablealsoshowsthe95%percentileofmessagetransmissiondelays.
Table19showsthesameresultsbutwithSIPmessagecompressionenabled.Herewecanob-servethatcompressingmessagesimprovesignal-lingdelaysontheRANsignificantly.However,delaysinthecorenetworkstaythesameasdecom-pressionofmessagestakesplaceintheP-CSCF.Table20showsdelaysforSIPsignallingflowsforthePagingInstantmessagingservice.ResultsareshownwithandwithoutSIPmessagecompres-sionandformeanvaluesand95%percentileoftotaldelays.
7.Conclusions
WehavepresentedanoverviewofSIP-basedmultimediaservicesproposedforimplementationinUMTSRelease5/6usingthenewIP-based
MultimediaCoreNetworkSubsystem.PartoftheoverviewwastoshowSIPmessagesflowsasso-ciatedwiththenewservicepropositions.Inordertoefficientlyimplementtheseservices,anSIP-basedpacketvoiceservice(voiceoverIP)andapresenceandinstantmessagingservice,wealsoproposedphysicalreferenceimplementationsoftheIMSinordertolimitexchangeofalargeamountofSIPmessagesbetweennetworkelementsoverexternalinterfaces.
Acomputersimulation-basedperformanceevaluationrevealedinterestinginsightintotheper-formanceofSIPmessageflowsfortheservicesweinvestigated.Aswastobeexpected,thelargeSIPmessagesizesandalsothenumberofmessagesre-quiredtosetupavoicesessioncontributetosignif-icantcallsetupdelayscomparedtocallcontrolsignallinginUMTSRelease99,whichisstillthereference.SIPmessagecompressionachievedareductioninsignallingdelayovertheradioaccessnetworks,however,aconsiderableamountofde-laywasincurredonthecorenetworkduetothelargenumberofmessagesandthenumberofnet-workelementsinvolvedinthesessionsetup.CorenetworkdelaywillneedtobeaddressedinfutureimplementationsofUMTSRelease5/6throughselectionofappropriatecomputingplatformsforSIPservers.Co-locationisalsoadesignoptiontoreducedelay.
PerformanceofSIP-basedinstantmessaging(IM)andpresencealsoimprovedwhenSIPmes-sagecompressionwasusedeventhoughdelayhereisnotascritical.ThemessagebodyofIMmes-sageswillrequirecompressioniflargeamountsofmultimediadatasuchasimages,audio,etc.,areincludedinthemessagetoreducetransmissiondelays.
Table20
Mobile-to-mobilepaginginstantmessaging(interactive)FlowID
Meandelay
(withoutcompression)RAN
PSsessionsetupSIPregistrationSIPsubscriptionLS
SIPsubscriptionpresentity
1.480.420.250.16
Core0.770.880.530.35
Total2.251.300.770.51
2.831.420.850.5395%Totaldelay
Meandelay
(withcompression)RAN1.480.320.180.14
Core0.770.880.530.35
Total2.251.200.710.49
2.831.290.750.5195%Totaldelay
D.Peschetal./ComputerNetworks49(2005)385–403403
References
[1]H.Kaaranen,A.Ahtiainen,L.Laitinen,S.Naghian,V.Niemi,UMTSNetworks,JohnWileyandSons,Chichester,2001.
[2]J.Rosenbergetal.,SIP:SessionInitiationProtocol,IETFRFC3261,June2002.
[3]M.I.Pous,G.Foster,A.Sesmun,V.Kenneally,D.Pesch,PerformanceevaluationofUMTSpacketvoicecallcon-trol,in:Proceedingsofthe5thEuropeanPersonalMobileCommunicationsConference,Glasgow,Scotland,May2003.
[4]I.D.D.Curcio,M.Lundan,SIPcallsetupdelayin3G,in:ProceedingsoftheIEEEISCC2002,Taormina,Italy,July2002.
[5]C.Urrutia-Valde
´s,A.Mukhopadhyay,M.El-Sayed,Z.Sayeed,D.Sun,SIPin3Gwirelessnetworks:Servicemodels,architecture,andnetworkdesign,BellLabsTechnicalJournal3(2004)101–126.
[6]M.Cortes,J.R.Ensor,J.O.Esteban,OnSIPperformance,BellLabsTechnicalJournal3(2004)155–172.[7]3GPPTS23.002,NetworkArchitecture,2002.
[8]3GPPTR23.922,ArchitectureforanAllIPnetwork,2002.
[9]3GPPTS23.228,IPMultimediaSubsystem(IMS);Stage2,2002.
[10]M.Handley,V.Jacobson,SDP:SessionDescription
Protocol,IETFRFC2327,April1998.
[11]3GPPTS24.228,SignallingflowsfortheIPmultimedia
callcontrolbasedonSIPandSDP;Stage3,2003.
[12]M.Day,J.Rosenberg,H.Sugano,Amodelforpresence
andinstantmessaging,IETFRFC2778,February2000.[13]3GPPTS22.141,Presenceservice;Stage1,2003.
[14]3GPPTS23.141,Presenceservice;Architectureand
functionaldescription;Stage2,2003.
[15]M.Dayetal.,Instantmessaging/presenceprotocol
requirements,IETFRFC2779,February2000.
[16]P.T.Brady,Amodelforgeneratingon-offspeechpatterns
intwo-wayconversation,BellSystemTechnicalJournal48(1969)2445–2472.
[17]A.Klemm,C.Lindemann,M.Lohmann,Trafficmodelling
andcharacterizationforUMTSnetworks,in:ProceedingsoftheIEEEGLOBECOM,November2001.
[18]Telecompetition,Inc.,3GWirelessdata—trafficcharacter-istics,UMTSForum,June2001.
[19]R.Priceetal.,Signalingcompression(SigComp),IETF
RFC3320,January2003.
[20]V.Kenneally,D.Pesch,I.Majumdar,EvaluationofSIP
compressionforIP-basedwirelessmultimediacommuni-cations,in:ProceedingsoftheIT&TConference,Water-ford,Ireland,October2002.
[21]I.Majumdar,V.Kenneally,D.Pesch,ImprovingSIPcall
controlperformancethroughmessagecompression—the
TCCBalgorithm,in:PresentationatSIP2003,Paris,France,January2003.
[22]3GPPTS34.108,Commontestenvironmentforuser
equipment(UE)conformancetesting,2002.DirkPeschwasborninKrefeld,Ger-manyin1966.HereceivedaDipl.IngdegreefromAachenUniversityofTechnologyin1993andaPh.D.degreefromtheUniversityofStrath-clyde,Glasgow,UK,in1999,bothinElectricalandElectronicEngineering.HewaswithNokiaMobilePhonesfrom1993to1995.From1996to1998hewasaresearchfellowwiththeMobileCommunicationsGroupinthe
DepartmentofElectricalandElectronicEngineeringatUni-versityofStrathclyde.Since1999hehasbeenalecturerintheDepartmentofElectronicEngineeringatCorkInstituteofTechnology.Heisco-founderandresearchdirectoroftheCentreforAdaptiveWirelessSystemsatCorkInstituteofTechnology.Heisaregularreviewerforanumberofinter-nationaljournalsandhasbeenontheprogrammecommitteeofanumberofinternationalconferenceincludingIEEEGlobe-com,IEEEISWCS,IFIPMWCN,EuropeanWireless,andothers.Hehaspublishedover45papersinpeer-reviewedjournalsandconferences.Hisresearchinterestsareintheareaofdesignandevaluationofalgorithmsandprotocolsformobileandwirelessnetworks,sensorandad-hocnetworks,andperformanceevaluationofmultimediaservicesinmobilenetworks.
MariaIsabelPousreceivedanengineeringdegreefromtheUniversityofValencia,Spainin2001andaMasterofEngi-neeringdegreefromCorkInstituteofTechnologyin2003,bothinElectronicEngineering.Sincelate2003shehasbeenwithaconsultantwithAccentureinMadrid.Herresearchinterestsareintheareaofperformanceevaluationofmultimediaprotocolsinmobilenetworks.
GerryFostergraduatedincommunicationsengineeringatPlymouthPolytechnicin1986.HeworkedatBritishAero-spaceuntil19designingcomponentsformicrowaveandmillimetrewavecommunicationssystems.HethenmovedtoSTCfortwoyears,wherehedevelopedmicrowavecompo-nentsfortheSquarialsatelliteflat-plateantennaandworkedonthecommunicationslinkforareconnaissanceaircraft.Next,hemovedintodatacomforBritishGas,whereheworkedonPMRmodemdesign,scanningtelemetry,under-water,andpipe-bornecommunicationssystems.In1997hemovedtoLucenttoworkonGPRSGSNs,andforthelastfiveyearshehasbeenatMotorolaworkingonUMTSsystemsanalysis.
因篇幅问题不能全部显示,请点此查看更多更全内容
Copyright © 2019- cepb.cn 版权所有 湘ICP备2022005869号-7
违法及侵权请联系:TEL:199 18 7713 E-MAIL:2724546146@qq.com
本站由北京市万商天勤律师事务所王兴未律师提供法律服务